Athens Pizzeria

Athens Pizzeria is a beloved family-run institution serving Cleveland since 1969. Known for its hearty, pan-style pies with a thick, crispy edge and a soft, chewy interior, it’s a West Side favorite for sheet pizzas you can feed a crowd. The menu is loaded with classics like Deluxe, Super Deluxe, Athenian, Pig-Out, and a nostalgic “Double Double” (double cheese, double pepperoni). Long-time fans rave about the generous toppings and strong value—especially their XL and half-sheet pies.